Skip to main content

Language: English / Gàidhlig

Loading…

Seòmar agus comataidhean

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Criathragan Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 5 May 2021
  6. Current session: 12 May 2021 to 21 April 2025
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 5477 contributions

|

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

Thank you. I call Edward Mountain.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

Do we need to be a little more honest, realistic and pragmatic about mortalities? Are we ever really likely to make massive improvements in the percentage of fish that are dying? Should we be looking at survival rates? The survival rate for farmed salmon would be significantly higher than the rate for salmon that are in the wild. It is about the narrative.

It seems to be pretty unpalatable that there is an annual mortality of 17 million fish, but it is a bit like comparing apples with apples. We are not talking about sheep or cows. The life cycle of different species of fish, whether it is salmon, wrasse, pollock or cod, is completely different. Rather than trying to defend what, on the face of it, would be unpalatable and unacceptable levels of mortality, is it not time that the industry and the Government took it on the chin and was honest about it? Could they admit that the mortality rate is to be accepted, that we should get over it and that that is how it is going to be? It is completely unrealistic to expect a 10 per cent mortality rate, given where we are with science, technology and innovation.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

It is probably a good idea to have a break before we move on to data accessibility and transparency, so I suspend the meeting.

10:17 Meeting suspended.  

10:30 On resuming—  

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

We will now continue with our questions on the back of the aquaculture report, turning to data accessibility and transparency.

Recommendation 11 of the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee’s report considered it essential that work on mortality reporting ensures

“high levels of transparency that will provide confidence to all stakeholders”,

and it recommended that the information

“provide an accurate, detailed and timely reflection of mortality levels including their underlying causes across the whole sector.”

That is something that we have spent time discussing.

Given that, as everybody appreciates, it is important to accurately report mortality, why has the Scottish Government not introduced a mandatory system for the reporting of mortalities, relying instead on the industry reporting them on a voluntary basis?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

We will be coming onto that and will explore those issues under other themes.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

Yes.

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

I have a couple of questions about the capacity of local authorities. A lot of weight is put on them when it comes not only to planning but to enforcement. Earlier, we touched on animal welfare cases. Before we move to questions from Edward Mountain, will you clarify local authorities’ role in referring welfare cases for prosecution? Given all their obligations, do you have confidence that our local authorities have the resources to do what is necessary?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

I understand how critical those numbers are, but it is difficult to get the figures right now, because we know that they are sometimes reported in different ways, whether that is based on biomass, individual fish or percentages. Given the questions that Edward Mountain has asked, could we have some clear indicators or comparisons from 2018 up to date for the committee to look over?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

We have a final question on this theme before we move to the next theme. Ariane Burgess, could you ask your supplementary question and then kick off on the environmental impacts theme, please?

Rural Affairs and Islands Committee

Salmon Farming in Scotland

Meeting date: 13 November 2024

Finlay Carson

Are you satisfied that the industry is currently working within those requirements, which, in your view, allow further expansion? How do you assess the industry as a whole? Once again, as I said, your vision was for the industry to be able to expand. How do you use those indicators to ensure that it is expanding and able to meet its obligations?

10:45