The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1752 contributions
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I am sorry to cut in, cabinet secretary—it is a bit of both. It is exactly what you say about quantifying evidence of the outcomes, but it is also about being able to evidence that that was the Government’s intention in the first place.
Last week or a couple of weeks ago, we had a witness who rhymed off the last half dozen of the Government’s major strategy documents across a range of portfolios. I will leave the PFG aside for the moment and come back to it. If I am getting this right, I think that four of the six documents made no reference to the national performance framework, and the other two made passing reference, but there was nothing specific about individual outcomes. Do you recognise the challenge there? How has it come about that the Government, which is, as you say, committed to the national performance framework, is consistently publishing high-level, significant documents to outline its strategy, but those documents do not reference the NPF? That is a problem, is it not?
11:45Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I think that Keith McDonald is looking to come in.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I do not disagree with you at all that the outcomes are what is important in this context and that that is primarily what the Government is held to account for. Nevertheless, do you recognise that there is also a leadership role for the Government here? The Government does not expect the NPF to be used only by the Government directly and public bodies more widely. The Government expects everybody—the whole of society and the whole economy, including business and so on—to embrace the national performance framework, so the Government itself should visibly embrace it. Otherwise, it is hard to see how the leadership role is being performed.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
Thank you. That is all from me.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I have a couple of questions about the national performance framework and local government finances, but before I get to them, I would like to follow up on Michelle Thomson’s lines of questioning, which I found interesting.
First, on air passenger duty—or air departure tax—and the subsidy control issue with regard to lifeline routes, are you able to confirm whether the new UK Government agrees, at least in principle, on the need to resolve that? We need to deliver on something that we all agreed to devolve 10 years ago, but we also need to protect support for the lifeline routes.
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I will move on to the other areas that I had planned to ask about. First, on local government finance reform, the joint working group with COSLA has not met since the Government changed back in April. Should we read much into that? Why has it been so long since that group last met?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
I absolutely agree on that. On exactly that point, what is your expectation for outcomes by the end of this parliamentary session on local government finance reform? Is there an ambition to have made a decision by March or April 2026 on council tax revaluation, a replacement system or additional new powers that are entirely separate? What is your expectation of where we will be? How much will have changed by then, or how much will at least be in motion by then, recognising that some of the reforms would be multiyear and quite complex ones?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
On exactly that, far from being perfect, council tax has not been in date in my lifetime, and I am now 30. Would you like to see revaluation in the current parliamentary session?
Finance and Public Administration Committee
Meeting date: 8 October 2024
Ross Greer
Thanks very much. I will return to the PFG, which the cabinet secretary presented a pretty rosy picture of. You argued that the inclusion is implicit rather than explicit, and you seemed to indicate that that was a deliberate choice. You made the point that the First Minister’s four priorities match the outcomes in the NPF and of course they do, because they are all very agreeable. The only reason why somebody would disagree is if they were a climate science denier; beyond that, it is all agreeable stuff.
However, it was a significant omission that the single most important document in the Government did not refer to the framework that the Government uses to measure whether it is building the kind of society that it wants. Would it not be easier to come here and say that that was an oversight and that it will not happen again?
Education, Children and Young People Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 2 October 2024
Ross Greer
Megan Farr made a point a moment ago—Gavin Yates or Garvin Sealy mentioned it, too, I think—about the fact that qualifications Scotland staff cannot make up a majority on a committee, although they could make up 49 per cent of it. Would you suggest amending the bill to have a lower cap on the proportion of the committee who can be staff of qualifications Scotland?