The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1447 contributions
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Liam Kerr
Good morning. My first question is to Liliana Torres Jiménez, and I remind colleagues that I am currently regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, of which I am a member.
Liliana, in your submission and opening remarks, you talked about your concerns about the definition of sexual acts and the proposed penalties. Could you expand on your concerns and tell us what needs to be amended to address them?
In your submission, you brought up the policy memorandum, which specifically says that the bill aims to
“reduce the amount of prostitution in Scotland”.
Will the bill, as drafted and/or amended, achieve that?
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Liam Kerr
You successfully pre-empted where I was going with that question about the contradiction between what Ash Regan told the committee on 25 June about not necessarily needing women’s evidence and your suggestion in your opening submissions. You referenced specifically the situations in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Is the matter of whether people in prostitution need to give evidence the only evidential challenge that has been faced there, or have you seen other evidential challenges that cause you concern?
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Liam Kerr
Yes, it does—thank you. I am going to press you, Dr Forbes, simply because your submission specifically says that the Crown Office is “mindful of the challenges” in enforcing the legislation in Ireland and is
“concerned that ... prosecutors in Scotland will face similar evidential barriers”.
What are those evidential barriers that you might face that would be similar? I am trying to understand that.
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Liam Kerr
You heard me earlier talk about the capital side of things. The SPA submission says that
“underinvestment in the police estate and technology remains one of the most pressing investment issues for policing”
and that the move to the single force has exacerbated that. The submission suggests that Police Scotland requires an increased capital investment of £93.9 million
“to deliver the basic rolling replacement programme of fleet, systems and policing equipment”,
which does not include some other things that would ideally be done. Again, this begs the question what would not receiving the increased investment mean for that basic programme, and what are the practical implications for policing?
Criminal Justice Committee Draft
Meeting date: 5 November 2025
Liam Kerr
I am very grateful, convener. Good morning. Chief constable, in your written submission, you set out that, should you not receive the additional £113.4 million funding requested for strengthening the front line, workforce modernisation savings will have to be identified. Can you put numbers on that in terms of officers? What would be the practical implications for policing, should you have to make those savings?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 29 October 2025
Liam Kerr
Cabinet secretary, in your opening remarks, you talked about the continuing rise in, and complexity of, the population. That is acknowledged, but that was all entirely predictable and has been known about for years—for example, as this place has been legislating. The measures to address this that you spoke about in your opening remarks clearly are not working to prevent overcrowding. In fact, in the submission that we heard about earlier, Victim Support Scotland said that the early release schemes
“are not effective in reducing the prison population in the medium or longer term.”
Therefore, how can the public be assured that, having previously endured the early release scheme and facing the release of a further 1,000 prisoners between now and, I think, April, we will not simply find ourselves in this situation again post-April?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 29 October 2025
Liam Kerr
That begs a further question: given that we are in this early release situation for short-term relief and that there have been previous early releases, what other solutions to provide short-term relief were considered in this situation that were perhaps different from last time?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 29 October 2025
Liam Kerr
I will ask two questions and will give each of our witnesses an opportunity to respond, starting with Dr Vuolajärvi. I want to pick up on the point about evidence that you raised during your opening remarks. What does the evidence tell us about the impact of the Nordic model—the criminalisation of the buyer—on the number of people who are involved in prostitution; the experience of those people of safety, stigmatisation and access to support; and the involvement of organised crime, including trafficking, in prostitution?
Criminal Justice Committee
Meeting date: 29 October 2025
Liam Kerr
Thank you very much for that. You will probably be asked about how it can be made better going forward.
I will bring in Professor Phoenix by asking a straight question. If this bill comes in and criminalises buyers, what will the impact of that be, based on the evidence that you have seen?
11:45