Skip to main content
Loading…

Seòmar agus comataidhean

Official Report: search what was said in Parliament

The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.  

Criathragan Hide all filters

Dates of parliamentary sessions
  1. Session 1: 12 May 1999 to 31 March 2003
  2. Session 2: 7 May 2003 to 2 April 2007
  3. Session 3: 9 May 2007 to 22 March 2011
  4. Session 4: 11 May 2011 to 23 March 2016
  5. Session 5: 12 May 2016 to 4 May 2021
  6. Current session: 13 May 2021 to 28 November 2025
Select which types of business to include


Select level of detail in results

Displaying 911 contributions

|

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

Thank you. Perhaps I could put that same point to Paul Lawrence or Elin Williamson from Edinburgh. In one of your previous answers, Paul, you were almost hinting that although Edinburgh was content with a percentage, allowing others to have a flat fee might be the way forward.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

Thank you very much.

I have one more question on the same territory. It is for VisitScotland, so it is for either Cat Leaver or Rob Dickson—whoever wants to answer it. It is specifically about economic assessment. In your written submission, you say:

“Before considering a levy, a local authority should examine the profile of their visitors—whether largely domestic or international—and the potential impact of a levy on businesses and visitors within the current economic and competitive travel landscape. Local authorities should also consider the potential impacts of a levy on factors such as price competitiveness and quality, visitor demand, occupancy and seasonality.”

That is a very clear statement of where VisitScotland is.

Given that, would you expect local authorities to be doing an economic assessment of the sort that Malcolm Macleod talked about, which Highland Council is now doing? Before introducing the levy, we would have a full picture, as opposed to the situation that I outlined earlier, where, for example, in Perth and Kinross, the levy is being presented in some quarters as, “This is something that could raise £9 million for the council. It is free money. What is not to like about all this cash coming in?” However, that does not look at the other side of the equation, which is to ask whether, if the levy is introduced, there will be a negative impact on visitor numbers.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

I am done. Thank you.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

It is interesting that you used the example of the levy in Venice, which has reduced numbers. To put the issue in context, I will give an anecdotal example from Perth and Kinross, which is part of the area that I represent. Perth and Kinross Council has a live consultation on a visitor levy in that area, on which I have had a lot of engagement with local businesses. That has been framed in such a way as to suggest that the levy could raise £9 million for the council to spend on measures that will benefit tourists and benefit the local economy. Framed in that way, it seems great—why would people oppose it?

However, I have not seen any studies—maybe you could enlighten me on whether any such studies have been done—on the negative impact that a visitor levy could have on visitor numbers. Are you aware of whether any work has been done on the economics of that?

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

That is a whole new can of worms that we could spend the rest of the day on. I will bypass it for the moment.

I have one more question for you—you touched on this in an answer to one of my colleagues. I think that you said that your convener had written to the Scottish Government suggesting that the council should be given the option of a fixed fee rather than a flat rate—sorry, I mean a flat rate rather than a percentage.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

I would like to bring in Leon Thompson on the same point, but also move on a little bit too. Marc Crothall shared with the committee some of the correspondence that the STA has had with Ivan McKee and the Scottish Government about the benefits of changing the model of visitor levy from a percentage to a flat fee. Can you explain a little bit about the rationale for that and why that is important?

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

I heard the other day that apparently you can get married there.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

That is very interesting because it suggests that the whole picture may be a bit more complex than people may have thought at the start.

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

I am sorry. I am not expecting you to make policy on behalf of the City of Edinburgh Council. Elin, do you want to come in?

Economy and Fair Work Committee

Tourism

Meeting date: 3 September 2025

Murdo Fraser

I think that that is a yes in answer to my question. Should detailed economic impact assessments be done?