Seòmar agus comataidhean

Do you have a timescale for that?

It would be good to get some information, because we are also hearing from industry that that is causing problems for it.

Rachael Hamilton talked about marine science being an outlier in Scotland with regard to publications. It is also an outlier internationally because it is not independent of Government. Is the current structure of marine science appropriate? Does it have sufficient resources and is it independent enough? Dr Robin Cook said to the committee:

“In laboratories across Europe and, indeed, in North America, science is managed at arm’s length from Government. The perception among other scientists is that those are more independent organisations. There is a lack of trust among people outside Government in Government science, because of the fear that it is being manipulated or influenced unduly.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, 4 September 2024; c 23.]

How would you respond to that?

When the committee visited the marine lab, we found it pretty grim, to be fair. We were at the Scottish Association for Marine Science on Monday, and the contrast with the working conditions of the marine lab staff could not have been greater. When do you expect to provide a solution to the simple building issues that are hampering people’s access to equipment and science?

Okay. That was not our understanding.

Obviously, not having access to some labs will have an impact on marine science. What impact is it having?

It does not concern you that output seems to be in decline compared to that of other international institutions.

I hear what you are saying, but it is surprising to me that the staff are able to publish anything, having seen the conditions that they are working in. I find it concerning that you do not think that there is an issue there.

Why has it taken so long?

Will that have an impact? Will the money be spent in time, or will communities and local authorities lose out?

When will the announcement be made?