The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1028 contributions
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 4 October 2023
Carol Mochan
My first point is that we are debating the fact that the rape clause is absolutely not fair—that is a given. I, personally, am not aware of the level at which the party has had such discussions, but I have made my position absolutely clear. The rape clause should go. When a Labour Government comes to power—a Labour Government is coming—we will make changes that make people’s lives easier.
I turn to the SNP Government and its motion. As other members have been, I am keen to outline some of the context for today’s debate. Just this week, we learned from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation that one in 10 Scots live in very deep poverty and that they make up almost half of those who live in poverty. The same report, which is rightly critical of the UK Government, maintains that the Scottish Government “could go much further”, and I agree. The focus of today’s debate should be on asking what this Parliament can do right here, right now, but the Government has chosen not to take that approach.
Labour members do not think that the current UK Government is setting a bar against which anyone should seek to compare themselves. Do SNP back benchers think that? I hope that they do not. We should be far exceeding the performance of a Conservative Government that has imposed austerity on our communities, wrecked the economy and hindered growth. The prominence of poverty—especially child poverty—in Scotland is devastating. I hear SNP members talking about that, yet it remains extremely prominent on the SNP Government’s watch. I have often asked myself why the back benchers do not challenge their leadership to go further. My ask is that they do so. A good Government comes from the pressure of those behind it. Is the Scottish Government merely doing a bit better than the Tories? Is that enough for SNP back benchers?
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 4 October 2023
Carol Mochan
Of course. I meant the SNP group that the member sits on.
Meeting of the Parliament
Meeting date: 4 October 2023
Carol Mochan
That was an excellent intervention from the nurse among us. I also had a career in the health service and I believe that we need to ensure that people see all the career avenues that are available to them in the NHS. It is a wonderful workforce to be part of. The Scottish Government has a responsibility to make nursing an appealing avenue for students.
I recognise that I need to conclude, Presiding Officer. I again thank Edward Mountain for bringing this debate to the chamber and I thank all the hard-working staff and teams who are around people who receive stoma care in our hospitals and our communities. I am sure that people also want me to thank the families for their support. It is good that we have had the opportunity to discuss the issue tonight, and I commit to ensuring that, if I am able, I will ask anywhere that has a disabled toilet to please place a shelf in it.
18:03Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 3 October 2023
Carol Mochan
Thank you very much, convener.
My question probably links with what has just been said, but I am interested in finding out whether and how the Scottish Government tracks spending by each NHS board on its current policy priorities.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 3 October 2023
Carol Mochan
It is. To come back on that a little, I note that sometimes—particularly with big spends—it can be hard to see where money has been moved about. Could we record anything differently, or better, to enable scrutiny and ensure transparency on where money actually goes once it is in the system?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 3 October 2023
Carol Mochan
There have been advances in relation to mental health budgets, which we can see more clearly. As you said, there is scope to look at other areas, which would be helpful for members and for the committee as a whole. Thank you.
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 3 October 2023
Carol Mochan
Good morning. I am interested in a couple of issues that follow on from Evelyn Tweed’s questions. Will you give us some idea of how sectoral bargaining might operate within the care sector in the future across the public sector, the third sector and the private sector?
Health, Social Care and Sport Committee
Meeting date: 3 October 2023
Carol Mochan
Lovely—that was very helpful. You mentioned engaging the trade unions. I am assuming that you will assure us that you will continue to work with the trade unions as we go through the National Care Service (Scotland) Bill.
My last question is, to what extent and in what ways do you expect the new accord with COSLA on shared legal accountability to address the concerns of trade unions about the bill? How will that agreement work as we move towards the national care service?
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 28 September 2023
Carol Mochan
I start by thanking Miles Briggs for bringing such an important debate to the chamber. As other members have done, I thank him and Monica Lennon for their personal letters.
I also thank Lucy, Holly, Zoe, Fiona, Peter, Andy, Gerry, Pauline, Irene, Caroline, Ann, Philip and Lorraine—I hope that I have not missed anyone—for sharing their heart-wrenching stories of love, loss and hope for the future.
It is unfortunate that we require to have this debate, but it is a reality that we must do so, because judgment and stigma continue, as we have heard. If our approach to changing that does not include accepting where we have gone wrong in the past and where we are not getting it quite right now, we are doing a disservice to those who already have become, or who could become, dependent, and their friends, their families and their communities. I say to all my colleagues in the Parliament that we must listen to their stories and seek to understand how and why stigma affects people and their loved ones while they are navigating an often tremendously difficult time in their lives.
I am not going to repeat the statistics that we have heard today, but every individual who has lost their life through alcohol or drug dependency is a loss before their time, and it must always be remembered that their friends and family have lost a loved one. Every life lost is an absolute tragedy.
This is a public health emergency and it must be treated in that way. That includes our being respectful and compassionate to others. The point about the way in which the media present the issue is important, and I call on all parliamentarians to challenge such language, because we know that it affects people.
Meeting of the Parliament [Draft]
Meeting date: 28 September 2023
Carol Mochan
Of course.