The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1202 contributions
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
What assurance can you give the committee that there will be no additional funding beyond what has been forecast by the CEO of the yard and agreed by the Scottish Government—that is, no more than £97.5 million for vessel 801 and no more than £105.1 million for vessel 802? What assurance can you provide that that will not be exceeded?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
You talked about the public’s anger about the delays and the cost overruns. This situation has been going on for eight years and there have been six ministers, but there have been no ministerial resignations. If there were to be any significant increase in costs or significant delays, would you resign, given that you have issued the direction?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
Good morning, Mr Gray. The assessment of value for money was detailed, but you said that it was narrow and that you had to set it against what you have described as a wider set of considerations. Can you provide to the committee or publish any detailed assessment of that wider set of considerations? You said that one of them was a conversation with Stuart McMillan, which does not sound particularly scientific.
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
Do you not think that, given that we are talking about the commitment of a huge amount of taxpayers’ money, ministers should undertake more than anecdotal or non-scientific assessments when they seek to override official advice?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
Do you have any niggling or on-going concerns about compliance in relation to the timeous publication of minutes and reports of meetings?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
You blame economic headwinds but, obviously, mistakes were made in the past. On that basis, should any of your predecessors have resigned?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
On 27 April, the First Minister said:
“It is my expectation and the Government’s expectation—the chair of Ferguson Marine knows this very well—that there should not be bonuses in the current financial year, 2023-24”—[Official Report, 27 April 2023; c 12.]
However, that was flatly contradicted at this committee by the chairman of the yard, Andrew Millar. Was the First Minister overspeaking or trying to somehow exert some remote pressure on the board?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
As the convener identified, it is the first time that written authority has been used since 2007. Will you explain in a bit more detail specifically why you thought that it was necessary to provide that written authority? What were you seeking to achieve and what were you seeking to avoid occurring?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
Should tight control of costs involve stopping any further bonuses?
Public Audit Committee
Meeting date: 22 June 2023
Craig Hoy
After what appears to have been quite a protracted period during which the audit and risk committee and the board did not meet, they both did so in November 2021. What was the catalyst for those meetings resuming, and, in your view, are the board and the audit and risk committee now meeting regularly?