Seòmar agus comataidhean

We have had 16 years of the SNP’s record on this and the number studying has gone from 354,000 to 236,000, which is a 33 per cent reduction. That is a hatchet job on the capacity of the college sector.

You are resorting to answer A again.

What is the total cost of the teachers’ pay settlement for 2023-24?

Therefore, my question to the minister is, where is the rest coming from?

That is a lot of money, minister. Where is it actually coming from?

So, I mean—

These are facts.

You can tell from the tone of my voice that I will do so.

The Scottish Conservatives’ position on that, as you well know—I do not want to have it mischaracterised—is that we also support paid tuition fees. However, we understand that issues arise with those. When someone like Sir Peter—who is widely respected not only in Scotland or the United Kingdom but throughout the world—raises issues around other ways in which Scottish students might be able to get university places, we think it worth having a calm and considered debate. I am glad that you have done so, but when I heard the First Minister’s response I thought that perhaps he had not read the article. He immediately shut down the argument.

None of us is saying that there should not be paid tuition; we are saying that we should look at other ways in which we can expand revenue streams for Scottish universities. I am not saying that that should involve Scottish families paying tuition fees for their sons and daughters to go to Scottish universities, but if it did, that can only be a good thing, surely.

That would not make sense—no.