Seòmar agus comataidhean

I will bring in Katie Hutton.

Oh—you are on mute.

Are you saying that there are too many strands? Generally, the education landscape in Scotland is quite cluttered. Is that true in this sphere, too?

Strategic relationships are what you might be describing there.

You are saying that, in effect, the levy is a training tax. Businesses might have been spending or planning to spend that money on training, so you can understand where Willie Rennie is coming from if those businesses say, “Actually, our margins, profitability and budgets are not sufficient to sustain an additional payment towards training.” That is understandable, is it not, from a business point of view?

Thank you, Oliver. We turn finally to Ross Greer, who is now on a stable link.

Do you mention the 4 per cent because you think that it should be more?

Some people might say that apprenticeship is a higher road rather than an equal road.

That is good, Frank. Michael Marra has a short supplementary question.

Is that question for Frank Mitchell or Allan Colquhoun?