All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 1870 contributions
Social Justice and Social Security Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 27 March 2025
Bob Doris
I am listening carefully to you, Mr Balfour, and I am not sure what I feel about your amendment, but my question is about something that is not in it. A lot of survivors of domestic abuse are under threat of losing homes in the private rented sector. There are some landlords who are not working at scale and have just one or two registered properties, but there are many large, almost industrial, landlords and letting agencies out there. Do you feel that this should also be a requirement on private landlords and letting agencies?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
As we know, the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee is leading on the Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill, but this committee will have an active interest in that piece of legislation, too. In that respect, what are your initial views on the function being given to you by the bill, and your capacity, to be the independent review body, and will that impact on any of your other functions?
I have to say that I was distracted by the financial memorandum in that regard. I note, for the record, that it estimates that
“to monitor, assess, review and report on the progress made towards meeting ... targets and the Scottish ministers’ review of those targets will require 5.5 to 10 full-time staff members, costing between”
£467,000 and £819,000. What level of funding do you need to ensure that this does not impact on ESS’s other functions? That question is for Dr Dixon or Mark Roberts.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
You might say that, Mr. Roberts, but the figures that I saw ranged from around £467,000 up to £819,000. In other words, we are talking about headroom of almost 80-plus per cent above what you think the minimum required to carry out those functions would be. It is a massive range, and if a minister came forward with it, they would be put under quite severe scrutiny. Why is there such a dramatic range in costs? Moreover, do those figures also include the £100,000 of additional money that you contend will be needed for consultancy fees, or are we talking about another £100,000?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
We are not the Finance and Public Administration Committee, but I am minded to note that the cost could be between half a million pounds and £1 million.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
You could be completely right about all of that, Mr Roberts—I am merely questioning the numbers. That is my job here today.
My final question on this issue is this: if we were to approach the £800,000 figure, would it be possible to get in-house expertise so that you did not have to rely on consultants?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
For clarity, are you saying that to get everything that you want to meet these responsibilities in—and I hate to sound glib about it—an all-singing, all-dancing way, the cost would not be £819,000 plus the £100,000 in consultancy fees?
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
I am sorry—I thought that you said the opposite. So, we would be nudging £1 million.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
That was helpful. Thank you.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
So, unless my briefing paper is wrong—and I am looking at the convener when I say this—it appears that the cost would be £819,000 plus another £100,000.
Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 March 2025
Bob Doris
Would it be reasonable, Mr Roberts, to have a core range of provisions that are costed, with the ability to flex up and get additional expenditure in years 2 or 3, instead of seeking the best part of a million pounds in year 1?